Canadian MPs sing 'God Save the King' after killing bill that would have made oath to Charles optional

Canadian MPs sing 'God Save the King' after killing bill that would have made oath to Charles optional

WATCH NOW: MPs sing God Save the King in Canada

GB News
Dorothy Reddin

By Dorothy Reddin


Published: 11/04/2024

- 10:45

Updated: 11/04/2024

- 12:01

MPs broke out into song inside the Canadian Parliament

  • Canadian MPs were voting on a bill that would have made the oath to King Charles optional
  • Canada is a Commonwealth country
  • Have your say: Should the oath to the King be made optional? Just click the comment button above now

Canadian MPs sang "God Save the King" after killing a bill that would have made the oath to King Charles optional.

The bill, voted against by a cross-partisan group of MPs, would have allowed parliamentarians to not swear an oath of allegiance to the King.


This vote marked a victory for monarchists eager to maintain the Crown's relevance in Canada.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's cabinet and most MPs voted against the private member's bill.

Justin Trudeau and King Charles

Justin Trudeau is the Prime Minister of Canada

Getty

However, Bloc Québécois and many NDP MPs voted in favour of legislation that would have diminished Charles's role in Parliament.

The final result was 113-197, meaning Canada's Constitution will remain as it was originally written.

Section 128 requires that every new parliamentarian swear they will be "faithful and bear true allegiance" to the reigning monarch.

Under Canada's constitution, an MP cannot legally assume their seat until they have taken that oath.

Speaker Greg Fergus

Under Canada's constitution, an MP cannot legally assume their seat until they have taken that oath.

CBC

C-347, introduced by New Brunswick Liberal MP René Arseneault, would have allowed MPs and senators to swear an "oath of office".

The stripped-down oath would have instead said: "In the best interest of Canada while upholding its Constitution."

The bill's defeat was met with major applause from monarchist MPs who spontaneously started singing God Save the King.

Speaker Greg Fergus shouted "Order" as MPs ignored his calls for quiet in the chamber.

Speaker Greg Fergus

Speaker Greg Fergus shouted "Order" as MPs ignored his calls for quiet in the chamber.

CBC News

King Charles and Princess Diana

King Charles and Princess Diana visiting Canada in 1991

PA

Meanwhile, Canada's republicans welcomed the bill as they view the monarchy as an outdated institution.

Pierre Vincent from Citizens for a Canadian Republic told CBC News that Arseneault's bill would do away with an oath that violates free speech.

Polls suggest that Canada is split on whether to cut ties with the monarchy, with 56 per cent voting against the institution last year.

However, Prime Minister Trudeau has said there is no appetite for a constitutional battle on King Charles.

You may like