BBC blasted for snobbish portrayal of working-class as 'miserable and in despair'

Employees arrive at Broadcasting House, London

Employees arrive at Broadcasting House, London

PA
Jack Walters

By Jack Walters


Published: 27/06/2023

- 11:16

Updated: 27/06/2023

- 12:02

Less than half of working-class Britons believe the BBC shows a ‘good range a programmes that include people like me’

The BBC only wants to portray working-class people as “miserable, broke or in despair”, a former presenter has claimed.

Lord Melvyn Bragg, who hosted Radio 4’s In Our Time for a quarter of a century, argued people from his background are under-represented in the media.


The 83-year-old, who grew up in Carlisle and is the son of a publican, said: “I did a book called Back In The Day, which was about my background – white working class.

“I wanted them to be represented. They’ve always been underestimated.

Melvyn Bragg arriving for the 2012 South Bank Sky Arts Awards at the Dorchester Hotel, Park Lane

Melvyn Bragg arriving for the 2012 South Bank Sky Arts Awards at the Dorchester Hotel, Park Lane

PA


“The BBC is probably to blame for this because they only want working class people if they are miserable on their book readings and things, but 70 to 80 per cent of the population comes from much the same background as I do.

“They’re massively underrepresented. I want to say, ‘Look, people like this, they worked so hard. And yet they came up from the mines. They came in from factories. And what did they do? They created a huge culture’. That was completely unrecognised.

“These people are [portrayed] as either miserable, broke or in despair. It wasn’t like that – and it needn’t be like that.”

Lord Bragg, who was appointed as a Labour peer by Tony Blair in 1998, started out at the BBC in the early 1960s.

LATEST DEVELOPMENTS:
BBC’s Tim Davie claims broadcaster has had ‘good year’ for impartiality despite Gary Lineker row
BBC ‘not doing themselves any favours’ with Casualty’s 'extremist' top surgery scene
BBC hit by major cyber attack as urgent investigation launched

BBC headquarters

BBC headquarters

PA

He also worked for rival channel ITV and headed up its arts programme The South Bank Show.

The programme was axed in 2010 and moved to Sky Arts two years later.

However, Lord Bragg previously addressed the media’s portrayal of working-class people in 2014.

The 83-year-old, who hosted BBC Radio 4 documentary series In Our Time since 2014, said at the time: “I’m not a fan of the working class being mocked, including by some of our famous writers, even by those who came from it.

Author and broadcaster Melvyn Bragg

Author and broadcaster Melvyn Bragg

PA

“All this ‘it’s grim oop north’ sort of stuff.

“Well, it was a joke once but we’ve got to the stage where the working class has been turned into a cliche – and it deserves a lot better.”

But Bragg’s latest comments come one year after the BBC was criticised by Ofcom for failing to resonate with working-class viewers.

Ofcom’s annual report revealed working-class people, who make up around one-in-four Britons, were least satisfied with how they are represented and portrayed in programmes.

The BBC’s annual plan released last year put forward a plan for 25 per cent of staff to come from lower socio-economic backgrounds by 2027.

You may like