Ben Habib warns of Britain's criminal justice system being 'dumbed down' amid calls to scrap jury trials: 'Not a good idea!'

WATCH NOW: Ben Habib blasts calls for scrapping jury trials

GB News
Georgia Pearce

By Georgia Pearce


Published: 12/12/2024

- 21:30

The Government is considering whether to reduce the number of jury trials in a bid to clear a backlog in the court system

Former Reform UK Deputy Leader Ben Habib has launched a scathing attack on proposals to remove jury trials from the British justice system.

Speaking to GB News, Habib warned that such a move would represent a significant "dumbing down" of criminal justice procedures.


The prominent political figure drew from his personal experience as a former juror to argue against the suggested reforms.

He insisted that having a diverse group of people examining a case was far more effective than relying on the judgment of a single person on the bench.

Ben Habib

Ben Habib voiced his concern for the scrapping of juries in court trials

GB News

"Jury trials are really important," Habib emphasised, expressing his firm opposition to any attempts to alter this cornerstone of British justice.

Habib drew upon his firsthand experience to make a compelling case for maintaining jury trials.

"When you get a cross-section of people looking at a particular case, they are much, much more likely to come to the right answer than an individual sitting on a bench," he explained during his GB News appearance.

His argument centred on the collective wisdom that comes from having multiple perspectives examine a case.

Stock image of jury

The Government is considering whether to reduce the number of jury trials in a bid to clear a backlog in the courts system

Getty

Habib referenced a recent case involving Levi Fishlock and a migrant hotel in Rotherham.

LATEST DEVELOPMENTS:

He expressed concern about the judge's handling of the case, particularly regarding their focus on racism.

"I heard the judge talk about this man's racism, and I was thinking to myself, his racism is not the relevant issue right now," Habib stated.

He suggested the judge had become "clearly hijacked by the whole kind of racist, anti-immigrant debate thing".

In contrast, Habib argued that a jury would provide a more balanced perspective.

Ben Habib

Ben Habib claimed the move would 'hollow out' the criminal justice system

GB News

"If you have a jury looking at it collectively, they're much more likely to come to a dispassionate, clear-minded, sensible solution," he said.

Habib concluded his argument by highlighting alarming statistics about the current state of the justice system. "As it is, only 2 per cent of serious crimes result in a conviction," he revealed during the interview.

He emphasised the gravity of this figure, urging viewers to "get that in your head: Only 2 per cent of serious crimes result in a conviction."

He argued that juries are "much, much more robust at getting to the right answer".

Removing this crucial element, Habib concluded, would represent yet another step towards "the hollowing out of our criminal justice system".

You may like